King John
Act 4 – “I am amazed, methinks, and lose my way
Among
the thorns and dangers of this world.”
Shakespeare
knows how to create a labyrinth within a plot and use verse to create hedges
high and pathways both simple and complex. He seems to be a man of his age but
sometimes he titters on the edge of Elizabethan beliefs and looks over the edge
to see glimpses of a humanism and individualism that lies as tantalising
landscape for England's and for Europe's furure. Is it fate or the actions of
men that pull King John down? Shakespeare opens up a world of possibilities.
Arthur is
to be killed by Hubert and his executioners. The scene is harrowing and an
audience that had witnessed 'Titus Andronicus' just a few years before must
have been feared the worst since little was known of Arthur, his life or his
death. Arthur’s youth and his pleadings to keep his eyes even at the expense of
loosing his tongue, along with the fire burning too low to make the
eye-piercing iron burn enough to pluck out Arthur’s eyes are strong companions
and Hubert is moved to pity. Personally, I think it was the beautiful
unraveling of metaphors and imagery that melts Hubert’s heart such that he
cannot bring himself to kill Arthur.
“The
iron of itself, though heat red-hot,
Approaching
near these eyes, would drink my tears
And
quench his fiery indignation
Even
in the matter of mine innocence;
Nay,
after that, consume away in rust
But
for containing fire to harm mine eye.”
Hubert
does not kill Arthur on the condition that Arthur will not reveal himself as
being alive.
King John’s
happiness at being back in England is short lived. He even plans a second
coronation for himself. Pembroke and Salisbury ask for Arthur to be released.
Hubert enters and lies to King John telling that Arthur is dead. When King John
announces this, Salisbury and Pembroke rebuff him and announce their intention
to attend Arthur’s funeral.
Just when
King John is just coming to terms with the fact that his actions may have
weakened the throne and his place on it when he receives the news that his
mother has died and that a huge French army is arriving to attack his kingdom.
King John, wracked with grief at the loss of his mother seems unable to take
action of any sort. Enter The Bastard, with news of the success of his
monastery plunderings and also with news that people are prophesying the demise
of King John’s reign by the next national holiday. Why King John does not just
simply cancel the next national holiday, I don't know. King John orders the
death of one such ‘prophet’ and ties to blame Hubert for Arthur’s death
claiming that it is not exactly what he had ordered. Hubert shows him the death
warrant sign by King John but the king continues to blame Hubert. At the last
moment, Hubert reveals that in fact Arthur is still alive. King John is wrapped
and shows some remorse for his blame shifting exploits. King John foolishly
thinks that all will be well now for him and his reign. But Fortune’s wheel
once turned has the momentum to run its own course.
Arthur
stands on the edge of the castle wall where he is held. He makes the rash
decision to try to escape while he can by jumping, even though even he thinks
the walls seem too high. Arthur certainly is not one who has shown great
instinct or judgement and he dies from the injuries of his attempt at escape.
Salisbury
and Pembroke arrive at the same castle discussing secret talks that are already
being made with Louis and France. The Bastard enters trying to speak for King
John and the interests of the crown. His pleas fall on deaf ears. Then Hubert
brings the news that Arthur was not killed but is still alive. No-one believes
him and he is accused of lying and being a murderer. The body of Arthur is
found and Hubert, the King and foul play is presumed. Salisbury and other lords
turn coats to join the Dauphin and the French forces which steadily approach.
Hubert is
left with The Bastard and pleads that he did not kill Arthur but that he had
granted Hubert mercy and that Arthur was alive when Hubert saw him last. The
Bastard seems to believe him and they exit preparing to see the king and
prepare for battle with not much hope in his heart for victory.
“Now
powers from home and discontents at home
Meet
in one line; and vast confusion waits,
As
doth a raven on a sick-fall'n beast,
The
imminent decay of wrested pomp.”